Governor Beshear needs to stop bullying school districts over COVID shutdowns

Kentucky Governor Andy Beshear announced on Monday that because of lingering concerns about the COVID-19 pandemic he was "recommending" all schools remain closed to in-person learning until September 28. According to former Kentucky School Boards Association spokesperson and education media watcher Brad Hughes, as of 10 p.m. on Tuesday night 48 of Kentucky's school districts had already announced they would comply with the Governor's "request."

Many parents, educators, and others have been shocked by this latest news given the massive efforts undertaken by districts to accommodate families who wanted in-person learning (with extremely complicated COVID precautions) and others who wanted a virtual option. They were also dismayed by the speed at which districts quickly agreed to the Governor's recommendation.

But in truth Governor Beshear was not making a recommendation at all. Superintendents had received the clear message from the Kentucky Department of Education that they better do as the Governor says - or else. In public webcast calls with Interim Commissioner Kevin Brown on Tuesday, August 4 and again on Tuesday, August 11 (watch starting around 15;20 for the next 8 minutes), Brown said that he and the Governor prided themselves on the fact that every single school district had bowed to previous requests to close to in person instruction.

If any district "chose" to open this time, they could expect a call from Commissioner Brown, the Kentucky Board of Education chair, the Governor, and state health officials who would try to change their minds - and perhaps the districts should have their attorneys there too. "My goal would be to have a different outcome at the end of the conversation and that would be a goal that would be achieveable," Brown said.

If districts continue to resist the recommendations, Brown said the Governor could issue executive orders to force their compliance, or public health officials could shut down their buildings or the KBE could issue an emergency regulation forcing them to do so. But it's all going to start with "a very intimate discussion if your district is one that decides to defy the recommendation." 

Kentucky educators decried former Governor Matt Bevin's "bullying" when he said mean things about their resistance to his ideas for pension reform. Where is the outcry when the Beshear administration tries to coerce districts into closing statewide, especially when many rural districts have had extremely few cases, and when data suggests (especially young) children are at low risk for getting or transmitting the virus?

Why is Commissioner Brown doing this at the behest of Beshear? Why has no member of the Kentucky Board of Education challenged these heavy handed tactics on the part of the Commissioner? Is it because Governor Beshear fired board members the last time they took positions at odds with him and had new members fire the previous Commissioner, effectively destroying the independence of KBE, an illegal power grab that the state legislature refused to stop or repudiate? 

Why are superintendents and educators not screaming in protest over Beshear's disingenuous use of the word "recommendation" and his annhilation of local autonomy? Had former Governor Bevin or former Commissioner Wayne Lewis done these things superintendents would have lit up the media with their complaints and educators would have marched on Frankfort.

So what is different? Is it because educators used their considerable political influence to get Beshar elected? Is it because the Kentucky Education Association, which last week demanded a statewide closure of schools if test rates stay above 5 percent, donated over a million dollars to Beshear's election campaign?

Andy Beshear is the governor the education establishment wanted. And now he's proving himself even more of a "bully" than his predecessor when it comes to forcing his views on our schools and districts. 

But it's not too late for educators to stand up for the students they serve. As of today over 120 school districts are still waiting to decide how to respond to Beshear's "recommendation." Will any of them have the courage to tell him no and fight for their local communities and local autonomy?

Comments

[Judy Schmitt]

Kids need to be back in school. In-person for their mental health!

[Lori L Alvey]

Kids need to be back in school! My child needs face to face in class room setting!

[Charlie]

Kids do need to be back in school, that is true. But the students and staff need to be protected also. Our lives, staff and students, are more important than physically being in a classroom or participating in an extracurricular activity. Why should we put ourselves in a greater risk situation? Over 50% of the staff are in higher risk groups, including their family members. What will mom and dad do when their child comes home and everyone ha to be quarantined? From where will the substitutes come if a staff member is quarantined or become sick? How will these situations improve the education process? They would still be remote learning and not in-person. Why must educators always be the sole solvers of our socio-economic problems?

States that have jump to start in person with little enforcement of protective procedures and higher infection rates are now backtracking and having to change course on a fast moving, narrow and rocky stream. Which leads to more problems than if they had slowed down and better assess the situation.

At least in Kentucky, most districts were planning for both situations. Now we can do a better job at both. Focus over the next 1.5 weeks plus at setting up and delivering a better virtual environment. Then, start to focus on delivering a better, though compromised, in-person experience once we return to the building

[Unknown]

My daughter is an assistant principal in a school system, she came to pick up her boys Monday and was in tears because of Andy Beshear’s deciision. She has a son starting kindergarten and one in 4th grade. Our children NEED to be in “in person” school. It is affecting them in ways we may not realize for years to come!!!!

[Starla Buckley]

First, Beshear is no where near the bully Bevin was. I don’t consider Beshear a bully at all. Our district chose in-person as an option for parents and I am glad we did. I think our kids need to be back in school if at all possible. I can easily explain to you why there is no out cry. I doubt there was a single educator in the state that supported what Bevin was trying to do to teachers. Nor was there a single teacher that wasn’t hurt and angered by the horrible things he said about us. This situation is totally different because many teachers do support his decision to shut down and go completely virtual. I teach in a building where people have opinions for both and we respect each other’s opinions. In no way has Beshear belittled or degraded teachers or the teaching profession. We really can get through this together even when we RESPECTFULLY have differing opinions on what is best.